Friday, May 14, 2010

Thought versus Action

Anyone whose deeds exceed his wisdom, his wisdom will endure; anyone whose wisdom exceeds his deeds, his wisdom will not endure. (Mishna, Avot 2:13)
Action is the main thing, not study. You should see to it that your practical achievements are greater than your intellectual development.                          (Rebbe Nachman of Breslov, Likutei MoHaRan II: 5, 15)
Yearning is of value only if you put it into action as a driving force for reaching higher levels. Otherwise, it will tend to create within you a subtle despair...In the end, you will stop yearning. (Reb Kalonymos Kalman Shapira, Tzav V'Ziruz: 23)
These thoughts - and others like them - always seem to scream out at me, sending chills up and down my spine. Many times these very concerns loom large in the forefront of my mind, and it's impossible to escape them. It is one of my greatest fears that I may end up losing sight of the big picture in my quest to amass more knowledge of HaShem, His ways, how humans fit into His plans, and how my role specifically is meant to play out in the grand scheme of things. While I don't believe that existentialism itself is inherently bad (despite Rebbe Nachman's exhortation), when it remains in the world of theory, without any practical application, what is it worth?

The fact is that one can learn numerous volumes of mussar, study many different philosophical approaches to understanding our world, and spend numerous study sessions unlocking the secrets of prayer, filling his siddur with underlines and highlighted markings. But if none of that is applied towards making the person into a better man through his utilizing those tools he acquired, then it is all a waste of time.

This is my fear: as I learn more, and gain more knowledge (aside from the fact that I continuously learn how much I really don't understand), how do I use it? Do I look down my nose at my less "educated" brethren as they "fumble through their darkened lives", or do I try to relate to them by focusing on their positive aspects? How can my studies be justified it they only enable me to see my fellow Jews with a critical eye? Is that the goal of all these endeavors? Why should that be? The study of thought and hashkafah do not guarantee anything without dedicated attempts at self rectification, and certainly doesn't place the philosopher on a higher pedestal solely by virtue of his scholastic achievements. The uneducated man who prays to God with a certain simplicity can teach the philosophy student the experiential wonders of true prayer which can not be described in any book adequately. If I could pray with truth and simplicity just once like that in my life, it would be worth more than all the books in the world!

To become mired down in purely intellectual pursuits is antithetical to Judaism. We are a religion of action - with underlying intent, of course - and the primary manifestation of our intellectual pursuits in the name of God have to be through obeying His tenets and safeguarding His laws.

As we enter into the month of Sivan, when the Chag of Shavuos quickly approaching, we need to internalize this message - myself especially - in order to be properly prepared to receive God's gift to us, His holy Torah.
Remember, upon accepting the Torah, we said "Na'aseh V'Nishma" ("We will do and we will hear"; Exodus 24:7); the action precedes the thought - we want to do, it's our raison d'etre - and everything else comes afterwards.

Among other things, it is my fervent hope that this blog counts as an effort to put my thoughts into practice, both as an inspiration for others and as a catalyst for my own growth. Writing is a creative process that cannot be done passively, and I try to put a lot into my original posts. With that said, I still need feedback; your comments, critiques and observations are integral to this blog; they are a significant factor in this process, and they are invaluable.

The other day during a session of hisbodedus I composed a short prayer regarding the above. I was able to recreate most of it, and I plan to say it on Shavuos after I complete the Tikkun Leil Shavuos, which is a gloss of the entire Torah, pulling excerpts from every section of the Written Law as well as Oral Law:

HaShem! 
May it be Your will that I be able to properly utilize all my strengths, both mental and physical, in Your service, to faithfully carry out your commandments with fear and love, and great joy. Grant me the Wisdom and Understanding to distinguish between Ego and Emes (truth), so that I may have the Knowledge to internalize that which I have learned about Your creations, and assimilate the Truth therein to better serve You. Guard me from becoming lost in a forest of questions; clear a path for me, for I am coming to purify myself.  
Master of the World - my Father, my King! - all my learning is in order to proclaim the Torah's greatness and splendor; please protect me from the doubts that plague me, please remove the barriers that block my way, causing me to stumble time and again. Allow me to extract the profound from amongst the profane. Remove the covering from my eyes so that I see my fellow Jews with an ayin tov (a "good eye"), in order that I may be able to learn the true paths of worshipping You from them.                    
Without You, I am nothing, HaShem! 
Help me!
Help me!
Help me...                                                                                                                          

Thursday, May 13, 2010

Special Prayer For Today!

On Erev Rosh Chodesh Sivan (the eve of the first day of the Jewish month of Sivan) there is a custom to say a special tefilla (prayer) composed by the holy SheLaH, concerning children and their education.

The tefilla can be said any time really, but this day has a special significance, as the Revelation at Mount Sinai and the receiving of the Torah occured during the month of Sivan.

I'm going to post it in full for those who don't have access to a siddur (prayer book); click to enlarge.














Monday, May 10, 2010

Shavuos Preparations...

A shiur (lecture) from the Tolna Rebbe of Jerusalem on getting ready for Shavuos; it's worth a listen, if you want to get a taste for one of the more dynamic Torah personalities of our generation.
    Get this widget |    Track details  |eSnips Social DNA    

The shiur is originally available on the YUTorah website; it is courtesy of Rabbi Ally Ehrman, a rebbi in Yeshivat Netiv Aryeh (where the above shiur was delivered), who is a chossid of the Tolna Rebbe, and a close friend of mine. Enjoy!

Also, some suggested reading in anticipation of the upcoming Chag: I have always found Rabbi Eliyahu Kitov's book The Book Of Our Heritage (translated from the Sefer HaToda'ah) to be a valuable source of information concerning the Jewish calendar; Shavuos in particular has a wealth of reading material devoted to it in his book. Click here to get it!

Sunday, May 9, 2010

An Interesting Read Part II

More profound thoughts from Rabbi Nathan Lopes Cardozo, as an addendum to the essay of his that I posted previously:
What do we mean by professing that G-d is good and man was created in His image? When G-d allows and even causes unbearable pain to befall man, afflicting him with sickness, cruel death, earthquakes and the most horrible wars, there seems little room for these claims. If G-d, by our moral standards, cannot be justified for many of His actions, as we have suggested previously, how are we to revere Him?


Is pain, then, completely pointless in man's eyes, his suffering of no value, his perseverance to survive against all odds nothing but an emotional need to see purpose in his life while there really is none? Is G-d the only one who knows the story, refusing to give man any insight? And is this the G-d who is to be emulated by man?

Moreover, what do we make of the biblical claim that man was created in His image? If G-d is the cause of so much evil and pain, does this not pave the road for man to be cruel and evil, as he was created in that very image?

ANSWERS

Jewish tradition has never denied that G-d is the creator of evil. The Bible itself attests to this: "I make peace and create evil" (Isaiah 45:7). The sages never lived in a psychological vacuum denying the realities of life. There was no attempt to cover up all the terrible things that could befall man. They tried only to understand where evil belonged in the scheme of the divine creation.

When Jewish tradition claims that G-d is good, even in the face of all evil, it speaks the Truth. But it can only make that claim from within the system of divine purpose. "G-d is good" does not mean in the moral sense of the word but in the sense that there is ultimate meaning to man's existence, known only to G-d.

With evil abounding all over the world, it is clear that the "moral good of G-d," as generally understood by man, is not the whole story. There must be a reason for all this evil, but it can only be justified in terms of divine meaning, not in moral terms. The unfathomable meaning of all existence becomes clear the moment that evil becomes apparent. It is in the deviation and violation of G-d's own moral standards as expressed in the Torah and felt in the heart of man that it becomes clear that the purpose of the creation of the world requires G-d's "teleological suspension of the ethical." The world was not created for the sake of ethics; it was created for the sake of divine meaning.

… AND MORE QUESTIONS

To argue that evil needs to exist so that man can grow spiritually has no bearing here. We remain with the unanswerable question of why man needs to exist so as to be able to grow. True, the sages stated that man needs to examine his deeds when evil befalls him (Berachos 5a) and that the Holy One blessed be He brings suffering upon the righteous so that they may inherit the World to Come (Kiddushin 40b). But this does not shed any light on why evil needs to exist, since it does not answer the question of why man must exist to examine his deeds or why he must suffer to merit a share in the world to come. All these arguments are a posteriori.

This is not to imply that there is no meaning to man's suffering, or that pain has no function and moral dilemmas no purpose. Throughout history we have seen how much these have contributed to the spiritual and moral greatness of man. It is through these challenges that people of moral stature have emerged and inspired millions. It has certainly been meaningful in human terms. But this is so only because there is an a priori reason for man to exist that surpasses any reason for him to be moral. The latter can never be seen as man's ultimate significance. It is of secondary importance in the overall divine meaning of existence. It is a by-product, albeit a deliberate one that G-d intended.

In fact, it is in the absence of knowing why G-d created the world that man is able to find meaning. To be part of G-d's world and play a crucial role in it without knowing exactly just what role one plays, or why there is even a need for it all is by far the most profound awareness man can ever experience.

A LIFE OF GRANDEUR

What gives life its grandeur is living with the knowledge that one plays a role in some plan that is much greater than one can ever fathom. It is recognizing that the value of human existence is in living with fundamental questions which, like diamonds held up to the light, show the spectrum of colors without ever being able to unite all these colors in a well formulated position. The moment these questions would be answered, the light would dim and the colors refracted in it would lose their splendor.

Every answer is a killer since it destroys the art of searching, the very element that makes life exciting. A world that makes total sense is a world not livable. It is endless human curiosity, which can never be satisfied, that is the drive behind all meaningful life. It is not the knowledge of something that gives us joy. It is the relationship between what is known and what remains an ultimate question — that is what gives man the satisfaction of "being". Lacking this mystique, man can achieve nothing noble. It is G-d's gift to mankind, and for that He is to be revered.

It is this unknowable mystique that mitigates man's pain even when tortured. What raises our indignation against suffering is not the torment itself but its senselessness. What makes the anguish of a suffering child intolerable is the inability to raise it to the level of meaning. As such, it is the most disturbing form of "teleological suspension of the ethical." It is this particular case of a child's suffering, demonstrating the complete absence of divine justice, that proves morality is not at the core of all creation.

For man to truly live life he must live for the sake of G-d. Our love for G-d is tested by the question of whether we seek Him or His gifts. A G-d of only mercy is a G-d unjust. To live for His sake means to feel and sustain the ultimate "wherefore" that cannot be answered. This is what the Kotzker Rebbe meant when he said: G-d, I do not need to know why I suffer, but I want to know whether I suffer for Your sake. "For Your sake we are killed all the time" (Psalms 44:23).

It is possible for G-d to exercise mercy and benevolence only as long as His ultimate meaning for this world's existence is not violated. It is seemingly despite this divine purpose that mercy exists, not because of it. In this sense, mercy is a novelty because its existence may run contrary to G-d's purpose in creating the world. This may be a disturbing observation — it violates our understanding of who we believe G-d is and who we want Him to be — but it cannot be circumvented. It reminds us that G-d is not there for the use or benefit of man, nor does He fall within the parameters of man's understanding. No reason can be given for the nature of G-d because that nature is the foundation of rationality but not rationality itself.

It is in the image of this divine mercy that man was created in G-d's likeness. It is despite G-d's ultimate reason for the creation that man needs to live in His image. Man is asked to undo the amoral effects of G-d's ultimate purpose for His creation, since the need for morality is an integral part of G-d's being but is not His totality. G-d's demand that man live in His image is in partial contradiction to the fundamental purpose of His creating the world. It is only in its a posteriori intention that this demand can be made. Since man has no part in the reasons for this creation, he cannot play a role in its entire fulfillment; he can only do his part, which is to try to be ultimately good, as G-d's likeness. G-d's likeness is only His image, not His divine totality.
A lot more food for thought. Again, this article is courtesy of the Jewish World Review website.
.

Thursday, May 6, 2010

Enjoy!

From the Israeli band, HaMadregot. Beautiful, beautiful music. Hebrew lyrics are below, with the nekudot (vowelization/cantillation marks), along with a transliterated version...



שְׁפַל רוּחַ שְׁפַל בֶּרֶךְ וְקוֹמָה אֲקַדֶּמְךָ בְּרֹב פַּחַד וְאֵימָה
Shefal ruach, shefal b'rech v'koma; Akademcha, b'rov pachad v'eimah
לְפָנֶיךָ אֲנִי נֶחְשָׁב בְּעֵינַי כְּתוֹלַעַת קְטַנָּה בָּאֲדָמָה
Lefanecha, Ani nechshav - b'einai - k'tola'at ketana b'adama
מְלֹא עוֹלָם אֲשֶׁר אֵין קֵץ לְגָדְלוֹ הֲכָמֹנִי יְהַלֶּלְךָ וּבַמָּה
Melo Olam, asher ein keytz l'godalo; hachimoni, yehallelcha uvamah
הֲדָרְךָ לֹא יְכִילוּן מַלְאֲכֵי רוּם וְעַל אַחַת אֲנִי כַּמָּה וְכַמָּה
Hadarecha lo yechilun, malachai roum; v'al achat Ani kameh, v'chammah
הֱטִיבוֹתָ וְהִגְדַּלְתָּ חֲסָדִים לְךָ תַּגְדִּיל לְהוֹדוֹת כֹּל נְשָׁמָה
Heitivota, v'higdalta, chasadim; l'cha tagdil lehodot kol neshama
This piyut (hymn) was written by Rabbi Shlomo Ibn Gabirol, a Spanish poet and philosopher who was a contemporary of Rav Hai Gaon and a predecessor to Rabbi Moshe Ibn Ezra. He also wrote Shir HaKavod (Song of Glory, also known as Anim Zemirot) and Shir HaYichud (Song of Unity). Shefal Ruach is traditionally sung before Nishmas Kol Chai on Rosh HaShana.

The band HaMadregot is the spiritual yearnings of guitarist Hod Dayan and singer Ilan Demari brought down to this world through the power of music. Beautiful melodies and moods blend with original compositions and interpretations of classical piyutim and songs from across the spectrum of Judaism. I have been a great fan of theirs for quite some time...

Wow, another week gone by! Thank God that it just brings us right back around to Shabbos!

Enjoy!

Monday, May 3, 2010

Small deeds, big rewards.

My wife and I had a newly-wed couple over as guests for the Friday night meal this past Shabbos. We knew the husband, who had grown up in my wife's neighborhood and went to the same shul as my father-in-law; and older bachur, this man just got married at age 32. His wife is a convert from the Philippines, and while we were at shul, she and my wife were shmoozing, and the conversation came around to the subject of why she converted.
The story she told my wife is beautiful, and I believe that we have an obligation to spread the story around, for the valuable lessons inherent in it.

She grew up in a very religious Catholic home, where the catechism of the Trinity confused her greatly. One elder told her to "Pray to the Father", another told her "Pray to the Son", and yet another told her to "pray to the Holy Ghost". She was in dire straits, because she really wanted to pray - but she didn't know who she should pray to!

Realizing that the faith she had been brought up with didn't have the answers she sought, she began looking into other religions that were prevalent in her country. Islam had no sway over her; Buddhism didn't interest her at all...
She felt lost, and the constant pressure from her peers and family - who were convinced she had "the Devil" in her - began to feel overwhelming. As soon as she was able to move, after graduating from school, she headed for the United States.

What a culture shock! The relative reservedness of the Philippines left her unprepared for what she encountered after moving to Bayonne, New Jersey. Suddenly, random people would stop her on the street and begin conversing with her; strange men would make advances, attempting to get her phone number, take her out for a coffee, and the like. The freedom, the provocatively loose atmosphere seemed to saturate everything American, and it took serious adjustment.

One hot day, she was walking back to her apartment. On the way, she passed a young man dressed very strangely: he was wearing a black jacket and hat, and he had these funny strings hanging out of his pants. As the passed each other, she expected him - like so many other men in the past - to stop her, or get a good look at her in her very revealing clothes. To her astonishment, he averted his eyes, looking down to the ground as he hurriedly passed her.

She couldn't believe it! To be sure, she turned around to see if he would maybe turn back after they had passed each other and sneak a peek, but as far as she could tell, he kept going on his way without stopping.

In a place where everyone is looking to satisfy their urges, could such a thing be possible? Who was that boy? Upon returning to her apartment, her roommate informed her that the boy she had seen on the street was a Jew. Until that point, she had never seen a Jew, didn't know what a Jew was or looked like, knew nothing about Jews at all.

What she did know was that she would have to find out more about these "Jews" and their intriguing ways.

She began to ask around, and meet with Jewish folks and amass as much information as possible. What she discovered was a world of dedication, integrity, sincerity, and consistent commitment. She was hooked, and she began the long arduous process to convert to Judaism. Now, thank God, she is married, and beginning to build a Jewish home in the wonderful tradition of her adoptive forebears.
We simply do not appreciate the impact the slightest gesture, the smallest action, can make. I have no doubt that this Yeshiva boy does not know what he did, what an impression he made. And yet, when he gets "up there" (after 120, God willing), he is going to be presented with the myriads of z'chusim (merits) that will come about from every commandment and good deed faithfully fulfilled by this woman and her family, and he will receive credit for each one!

One act of shmiras einayim (guarding the eyes) led a woman searching for God in the right direction. How many times are we presented with choices on how to behave, and we have no idea who is watching? It's a very important lesson for all of us to internalize, and may we all act properly at all times, whether or not anyone is watching!

Sunday, May 2, 2010

Lag B'Omer 5770

I have always loved this day, for many reasons: it marked the end of the abstaining from music for me; as a kid, it meant that the school day had a slightly lighter atmosphere, usually involving a class trip to the park or some such activity; later on, the madurot (bonfires), accompanied by the singing and dancing as we celebrated the life and times of Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai; later still, the day took on special significance as the day of my wedding, two years ago today.

Who was Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai? Why is he referred to as the botzina kedusha (the Holy Lamp)? Why is the anniversary of his death a day of such celebration, and why do we celebrate the day the way we do, with dancing and bonfires?

We know that - historically speaking - a major part of the counting of the Omer involves the practices established to mourn the students of Rabbi Akiva, one of the greatest sages to ever live. After witnessing such a catastrophe involving his students - who were from the most venerable, wisest of men - Rabbi Akiva persevered and began to rebuild, taking in another five students. An important point to note is that - due to the fact that Rabbi Akiva was one of the Ten Martyrs, and we don't want to celebrate his life on the day of his tragic death - we include the celebration of Rabbi Akiva's life with that of his greatest student, Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai. Rabbi Shimon, who was the apotheosis of Rabbi Akiva's teachings, fully incorporating them into his life, and dedicating himself toward the dissemination of his master's Torah.

Indeed, Rabbi Shimon helped to ensure the faithful transmission of the Torah SheBa'al Peh (Oral Law), famously quoting the verse "For it will not be forgotten by their progeny." If you look at the picture posted below, you will see that the verse is written in the archway; the last letters of each word spell out "Yochai", while the verse quoted above it has it's first letters spelling out "Shimon".



Reb Shimshon Pincus OBM, once famously described Rabbi Shimon: rather than being the most scholarly of the students of Rabbi Akiva, with the most breadth of knowledge and grasp of concepts, Rabbi Shimon's strength lay in his ability to explain, to take very difficult ideas - ideas that are the foundation of creation and how everything relates to one another - and clarify their meaning in a way that our finite understanding can begin to grasp such matters. This ability to make things accessible to others was unique to the botzina kadisha, whose revelatory light paved the way for the teachings of the Zohar (which may or may not have been written by Rabbi Shimon himself).
 
Rav Tzvi Meir Zilberberg mentions how today - Lag B'Omer, which is the rectification of the sefira of Hod SheB'Hod (Splendor within Splendor) - is perhaps the most powerful day of the Omer, on top of the all around holiness of this time of year. The gates of Heaven are open, waiting to receive even the most pitiful of prayers, and one can literally change things for himself and his loved ones on this day. An important aspect of the rectification of this day is the increasing of unity among ourselves and our brethren. We celibrate in a way unique to the Jewish nation; we dance together, in a circle. A circle has no beginning, no end, it just continues around in a continuous fluidity (Rav Moshe Weinberger has a lecture on this specific topic that is worth listening to. Follow this link to listen to it, free!); this is symbolic of life itself, and illustrates the Oneness of the Jewish people. Rabbi Shimon himself encouraged his students to unite, because through their cohesiveness, they would merit to plumb the depths of the Torah...

For a few more stories and details about Rabbi Shimon, follow the label "Lag B'Omer" to a post from a few years ago...